Presto 16-Inch vs BLACK+DECKER Family-Sized Skillet: Which Should You Buy?
Last updated: 2026-09-12 · By NicheHive Editorial
This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, NicheHive earns from qualifying purchases. See our full disclosure.
The Presto 16-Inch (round, cast aluminum, largest surface) and BLACK+DECKER Family-Sized SK1215BC (12x15 rectangular, grease-draining tilt leg) are the two most-compared budget electric skillets. This comparison covers surface size, cleanup, and who should buy each.
Presto 16-Inch Electric Skillet with Glass Cover
- ✓16-inch round cast aluminum cooking surface
- ✓High-dome glass cover
- ✓Removable temperature control probe
- ✓5 fixed temperature settings
- ✓Dishwasher-safe pan body
Pros
- 16-inch surface is larger than the BLACK+DECKER's 12x15-inch cooking area
- Cast aluminum base resists hot spots better than stamped steel
- Highest ratings volume of the two, a strong long-term reliability signal
- High-dome cover has clearance for a whole chicken or a tall pot of chili
Cons
- No tilt leg for draining grease during cooking
- No side handles for easier carrying
- Round shape wastes some space on rectangular foods like chicken breast
Best for households that want the single largest cooking surface available and don't need a grease-draining feature.
BLACK+DECKER Family-Sized Electric Skillet SK1215BC
- ✓12x15-inch rectangular nonstick surface
- ✓Tempered glass lid
- ✓Cool-touch handles for table serving
- ✓Tilt leg for draining grease
- ✓Removable variable temperature control
Pros
- Tilt leg drains grease away from bacon and sausage without lifting the pan
- Rectangular shape fits sandwiches and chops more efficiently than a round pan
- Cool-touch handles make table serving safer and more comfortable
- Often the slightly less expensive of the two at typical pricing
Cons
- 12x15 surface holds less total food than the Presto's 16-inch round
- Nonstick coating wears faster than cast aluminum under years of heavy use
- Fewer total ratings than the Presto
Best for households that want a rectangular surface and a grease-draining feature at a slightly lower price.
Two of the most budget-friendly electric skillets on the market, and shoppers still land on different answers about which to buy.
Presto 16-Inch versus BLACK+DECKER Family-Sized is one of the most common budget electric skillet decisions, and the two split fairly cleanly along shape and feature priorities.
The Presto brings a 16-inch round cast aluminum surface, the largest single cooking area between the two, plus a high-dome glass cover with real clearance for a whole chicken.
The BLACK+DECKER counters with a 12x15-inch rectangular surface, a grease-draining tilt leg, and cool-touch handles built for table serving, all at a slightly lower typical price.
The real dividing line is what you cook most. Bacon and sausage lean toward the BLACK+DECKER's tilt leg, while raw feeding capacity for a big group leans toward the Presto's larger round surface.
The Short Answer
Buy the Presto 16-Inch if you want the largest single cooking surface available at this price, cook for 5 or more people regularly, or want a high-dome cover for taller foods.
Buy the BLACK+DECKER if you cook a lot of bacon or sausage and want the grease-draining tilt leg, prefer a rectangular shape for sandwiches and chops, or want cool-touch handles for table serving.
Spec Comparison
| Spec | Presto 16-Inch | BLACK+DECKER SK1215BC |
|---|---|---|
| Surface shape | Round | Rectangular |
| Surface size | 16-inch diameter | 12x15 inches |
| Base material | Cast aluminum | Nonstick coated steel |
| Cover | High-dome glass | Tempered glass |
| Tilt leg | No | Yes |
| Removable temperature control | Yes | Yes |
| Dishwasher safe | Pan body | Pan body and lid |
Where They Match
Cleanup convenience: Both use a removable temperature probe, so the pan body can go straight into a sink or dishwasher without risking the electrical components.
Everyday cooking performance: For eggs, sandwiches, and simple one-pan meals, both produce reliable, evenly cooked results without meaningful differences in day-to-day use.
Budget-friendly pricing: Both sit at the accessible end of the electric skillet category, well under the pricier ceramic-coated or wide-temperature-range models.
Where Presto Wins
Raw cooking capacity: The 16-inch round surface holds more total food per batch than the BLACK+DECKER's 12x15-inch rectangle, a meaningful advantage for larger groups or big camp breakfasts.
Even heating: The cast aluminum base resists hot spots more consistently than the BLACK+DECKER's thinner nonstick-coated steel base, particularly noticeable on large batches.
Cover clearance: The high-dome glass cover fits taller foods, like a whole small chicken, that would not clear the BLACK+DECKER's lower-profile lid.
Where BLACK+DECKER Wins
Grease management: The tilt leg is a genuinely useful feature the Presto does not include, letting rendered fat drain away from bacon and sausage automatically during cooking.
Shape efficiency for rectangular foods: Sandwiches, pork chops, and fish fillets fit the BLACK+DECKER's straight edges more efficiently than the Presto's curved corners.
Table-serving comfort: The cool-touch handles make it easier and safer to carry a full, hot pan directly from the counter to the table.
Who Should Buy Each
Presto 16-Inch: households of 5 or more, frequent large-batch cooking, want the largest available surface at this price.
BLACK+DECKER SK1215BC: frequent bacon or sausage cooking, prefer a rectangular pan, want table-serving convenience.
BLACK+DECKER Family-Sized Skillet on Amazon
See Also
- Presto 16-Inch Review, full Presto review
- BLACK+DECKER Review, full BLACK+DECKER review
- Best Electric Skillets Under $40, full budget category
Frequently Asked Questions
Our editorial team researches, tests, and writes every review independently. We never accept payment for placement.