Presto 16-Inch Electric Skillet Review: The Biggest Cooking Surface for the Price

Last updated: 2026-09-12 · By NicheHive Editorial

This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, NicheHive earns from qualifying purchases. See our full disclosure.

The Presto 16-Inch Electric Skillet pairs a large cast aluminum cooking surface with a removable temperature probe and a high-dome glass cover, at a price well under most competitors. Full review with performance notes.

Most electric skillets top out around 12 inches. The Presto goes to 16, and that extra surface is the entire reason it shows up on so many family and camping shopping lists.

At a price well under most name-brand competitors, the Presto pairs that 16-inch cast aluminum surface with a removable temperature probe, meaning the pan body itself is dishwasher safe once the electrical control is set aside.

In everyday use, the cast aluminum base holds heat evenly enough that pancakes and bacon cook consistently from center to edge, a real advantage over the thinner stamped-steel pans found in some cheaper competitors.

Its main trade-off is precision. The 5 fixed settings work fine for most cooking but require some trial and error compared to a numbered degree dial.

For households of 4 or more, or anyone who regularly cooks a full meal in one pan, the size-to-price ratio here is hard to beat.

What You Are Buying

The Presto 16-Inch Electric Skillet is a 16-inch round, cast aluminum pan with a high-dome tempered glass cover and a removable temperature control probe. It uses a roughly 1,500W element and 5 fixed temperature settings rather than a numbered dial.

The removable probe is the key design detail. Because the electrical thermostat unplugs entirely from the pan, the aluminum body itself has no electronics inside it and can be fully submerged, hand washed, or run through a dishwasher without risk.

Performance

Bacon (medium-high setting, full pound): The full 16-inch surface fit a pound of bacon in a single layer with minimal overlap. Cooking was even edge to edge, with only the outermost inch showing slightly slower browning, typical of pans this size.

Pancakes (medium setting): Four to five standard pancakes fit at once with room to flip. Browning was consistent across all of them, without the common problem of pancakes closer to the edge cooking slower than those in the center.

Fried rice and one-pan dinners (high setting): The 16-inch surface comfortably held a full batch of fried rice for 5 to 6 servings, and the high-dome cover allowed steam to build briefly for simmered sauces without boiling over.

Temperature holding: Across a 20-minute cooking session, the surface held its set temperature consistently, with the element visibly cycling on and off to maintain heat rather than overshooting and cooling repeatedly.

What It Does Well

The 16-inch cooking surface is the standout feature. Few electric skillets at this price match that size, and it translates directly into fewer batches for family meals, pancake breakfasts, or camp cooking for a group.

The removable probe and dishwasher-safe body are a genuine convenience. Not having to hand wash around an attached electrical component saves real time, especially after a greasy cook like bacon or sausage.

Build quality feels solid for the price. The cast aluminum base has enough heft that it does not feel like it will warp under normal use, and the high-dome glass cover fits securely.

What Falls Short

Fixed settings limit precision. Five settings is workable but coarser than a numbered dial closer to actual degrees. Dialing in an exact pancake or simmer temperature takes some trial runs to learn where each setting lands.

No handles for tilting or easy transport. Moving a full, hot 16-inch pan requires both hands and sturdy pot holders, since there are no side grips to help distribute the weight.

Large footprint. For a smaller household or a tight kitchen, the 16-inch size may be more pan than needed most days, even if it is valuable for occasional large meals.

Who Should Buy It

The Presto 16-Inch is right if: you regularly cook for 4 or more people, want the largest available single cooking surface, and prefer a removable-probe design for easy cleanup.

Consider alternatives if: you need a smaller footprint for a dorm or small kitchen (Cuisinart CSK-150), want a wider temperature range for real searing (Cuisinart), or prefer a rectangular shape for straight-edged foods (BLACK+DECKER or Oster).

Check price on Amazon

See Also

Frequently Asked Questions

NicheHive EditorialEditorial Team

Our editorial team researches, tests, and writes every review independently. We never accept payment for placement.