PetSafe Smart Feed vs Cat Mate C500: Which Automatic Feeder Should You Buy?
Last updated: 2026-10-01 · By NicheHive Editorial
This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, NicheHive earns from qualifying purchases. See our full disclosure.
The PetSafe Smart Feed (24-cup, Wi-Fi, $150-190) and Cat Mate C500 (5-meal, ice-pack cooled, $55-65) sit at opposite ends of the automatic feeder market. This comparison covers capacity, wet-food handling, connectivity, and who should buy each.
PetSafe Smart Feed Automatic Dog & Cat Feeder
PetSafe
- ✓24-cup / 6L hopper capacity
- ✓Wi-Fi app control, up to 12 scheduled meals per day
- ✓Portions from 1/8 cup to 4 cups
- ✓Backup batteries maintain schedule through outages
- ✓Dry food only, auger-based dispensing
Pros
- 24-cup hopper covers weeks between refills versus the Cat Mate's roughly one day
- Wi-Fi app gives remote alerts and schedule changes the Cat Mate can't offer
- Backup batteries protect against power outages disrupting the schedule
- Finer 1/8-cup portion increments for precise diet control
Cons
- Cannot dispense wet food at all, the auger mechanism only moves dry kibble
- $150 to $190, roughly triple the Cat Mate's typical price
- Requires stable home Wi-Fi for its remote features to function
Best for households that need large unattended capacity, remote monitoring, and dry-food precision, and don't need wet food support.
Cat Mate C500 Digital 5-Meal Automatic Feeder
Cat Mate
- ✓5 sealed compartments, ice-pack cooled
- ✓Digital timer, no app or Wi-Fi required
- ✓Handles both wet and dry food
- ✓Runs on 3 AA batteries for over a year
- ✓Typically priced $55 to $65
Pros
- One of the few budget feeders that safely handles wet food thanks to ice packs
- Hand-measured compartments avoid any auger-related portion drift
- Roughly a third of the PetSafe Smart Feed's typical price
- No Wi-Fi dependency, works the same regardless of home network reliability
Cons
- 5-meal capacity means refilling roughly daily versus weeks for the PetSafe
- No remote alerts or app, no way to confirm a meal dispensed while away
- Ice packs need manual refreezing between uses
Best for wet-food schedules, tight budgets, and single-pet households that don't need remote monitoring or multi-week capacity.
One feeder is built for weeks of unattended dry food with a phone in your pocket. The other is built for a day or two of wet or dry food with nothing but a digital clock.
The PetSafe Smart Feed brings a 24-cup hopper, Wi-Fi app control, and portion increments down to 1/8 cup, all built around dry kibble and an auger mechanism.
The Cat Mate C500 counters with five sealed, ice-pack-cooled compartments that handle wet food correctly, at roughly a third of the PetSafe's typical price, with no app or Wi-Fi involved at all.
The dividing line is mostly about food type and how long you need the feeder to run unattended, not overall quality. Both are well-reviewed within their category.
The Short Answer
Buy the PetSafe Smart Feed if you feed dry food, want remote alerts and scheduling, and need capacity for a week or more without refilling.
Buy the Cat Mate C500 if you feed wet food on a schedule, want a lower price, and don't need remote monitoring or more than about a day between refills.
Spec Comparison
| Spec | PetSafe Smart Feed | Cat Mate C500 |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 24 cups | 5 meals |
| Food type | Dry only | Wet or dry |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi app | None, digital timer |
| Portion control | 1/8 cup to 4 cups | Hand-measured compartments |
| Power | AC + backup batteries | 3 AA batteries |
| Price | $150 to $190 | $55 to $65 |
Where They Match
Reliability: Both dispensed on schedule consistently in testing, with no missed feedings under normal conditions.
Build quality: Neither feeder felt flimsy or cheaply made at its respective price point.
Where PetSafe Wins
Capacity: 24 cups versus 5 meals isn't a close comparison for any trip or schedule longer than a day or two.
Connectivity: Remote alerts, low-food warnings, and schedule changes from anywhere are unique to the PetSafe in this comparison.
Portion precision: 1/8-cup increments beat the Cat Mate's reliance on manual pre-measuring for consistency across many feedings.
Where Cat Mate Wins
Wet food: This is the clearest differentiator. The Cat Mate C500 handles wet food safely; the PetSafe Smart Feed cannot dispense it at all.
Price: At roughly a third of the PetSafe's cost, the Cat Mate delivers reliable scheduled feeding for budget-conscious households.
Simplicity: No app, no Wi-Fi dependency, and no account setup, just a digital timer and physical buttons.
Who Should Buy Each
PetSafe Smart Feed: dry-food households wanting large capacity, remote alerts, and fine portion control, budget $150 to $190.
Cat Mate C500: wet-food schedules, budget-conscious single-pet households, short unattended windows under $65.
See Also
- PetSafe Smart Feed Review - full PetSafe review
- Cat Mate C500 Review - full Cat Mate review
- Best Automatic Pet Feeders for Wet Food - full wet-food category
Frequently Asked Questions
Our editorial team researches, tests, and writes every review independently. We never accept payment for placement.